Sun May 24, 2009
- FINALRockies3Tigers1
- FINAL/11Phillies4Yankees3
- FINAL/11Guardians3Reds4
- FINAL/11Rays4Marlins5
- FINALBlue Jays2Braves10
- FINALOrioles5Nationals8
- FINALMets5Red Sox12
- FINALRangers5Astros0
- FINALPirates4White Sox3
- FINALRoyals3Cardinals2
- FINALD-backs2Athletics6
- FINALCubs2Padres7
- FINALAngels10Dodgers7
- FINALGiants4Mariners5
- FINALBrewers3Twins6