Mon May 25, 2009
- FINALAstros5Reds8
- FINALBlue Jays1Orioles4
- FINALYankees11Rangers1
- FINAL/10Cardinals0Brewers1
- FINALTigers13Royals1
- FINALRed Sox6Twins5
- FINALDodgers16Rockies6
- FINAL/10Padres9D-backs7
- FINALMariners1Athletics6
- FINALBraves2Giants8
- FINALRays10Guardians11
- FINALMarlins5Phillies3
- FINALNationals2Mets5
- FINALPirates10Cubs8
- FINALWhite Sox17Angels3