Tue May 26, 2009
- FINALRays1Guardians5
- FINALBlue Jays2Orioles7
- FINALMarlins3Phillies5
- FINALAstros4Reds6
- FINALNationals1Mets6
- FINALPirates1Cubs6
- FINALYankees3Rangers7
- FINALCardinals8Brewers1
- FINALTigers1Royals6
- FINALRed Sox2Twins5
- FINALDodgers7Rockies1
- FINALPadres5D-backs6
- FINALMariners3Athletics4
- FINALWhite Sox4Angels2
- FINALBraves0Giants4