Wed May 27, 2009
- FINALCardinals3Brewers2
- FINAL/11Blue Jays10Orioles12
- FINALTigers8Royals3
- FINALPirates2Cubs5
- FINALDodgers8Rockies6
- FINALMariners6Athletics1
- FINALRays7Guardians12
- FINALMarlins6Phillies2
- FINALAstros1Reds6
- FINALNationals4Mets7
- FINALYankees9Rangers2
- FINALRed Sox2Twins4
- FINALPadres8D-backs5
- FINALWhite Sox1Angels3
- FINALBraves3Giants6