Tue June 16, 2009
- POSTPONEDWhite SoxCubs
- FINALMets6Orioles4
- FINAL/10Blue Jays8Phillies3
- FINALNationals3Yankees5
- FINALBrewers7Guardians5
- FINALBraves2Reds7
- FINALMarlins2Red Sox8
- FINALAstros1Rangers6
- FINALD-backs0Royals5
- FINALPirates2Twins8
- FINALTigers2Cardinals11
- FINALRays12Rockies4
- FINALMariners5Padres0
- FINAL/10Athletics4Dodgers5
- FINALAngels8Giants1