Wed June 17, 2009
- FINALWhite Sox4Cubs1
- FINALAngels4Giants3
- FINALMets4Orioles6
- FINALBlue Jays7Phillies1
- FINALNationals3Yankees2
- FINAL/11Brewers9Guardians8
- FINALBraves3Reds4
- FINALMarlins1Red Sox6
- FINAL/10Astros4Rangers5
- FINALD-backs12Royals5
- FINALPirates8Twins2
- FINALTigers3Cardinals4
- FINALRays3Rockies5
- FINALMariners4Padres3
- FINALAthletics5Dodgers4