Tue June 23, 2009
- FINALYankees0Braves4
- FINALCubs4Tigers5
- FINALRed Sox11Nationals3
- FINALGuardians5Pirates4
- FINALReds5Blue Jays7
- FINALPhillies10Rays1
- FINALCardinals3Mets0
- FINAL/12Orioles6Marlins7
- FINALRoyals2Astros1
- FINALTwins7Brewers3
- FINALDodgers5White Sox2
- FINALRangers2D-backs8
- FINALRockies3Angels4
- FINALGiants4Athletics1
- FINALPadres9Mariners7