Wed June 24, 2009
- FINALYankees8Braves4
- FINALCubs3Tigers5
- FINALRed Sox6Nationals4
- FINALGuardians6Pirates10
- FINALReds2Blue Jays8
- FINALPhillies1Rays7
- FINALCardinals0Mets11
- FINALOrioles2Marlins5
- FINAL/11Royals4Astros3
- FINALTwins3Brewers4
- FINALDodgers7White Sox10
- FINALRangers2D-backs1
- FINALRockies3Angels11
- FINALGiants6Athletics3
- FINALPadres3Mariners4