Tue August 25, 2009
- FINAL/12Padres2Braves1
- FINALPhillies4Pirates6
- FINALRangers10Yankees9
- FINALRays7Blue Jays3
- FINALWhite Sox3Red Sox6
- FINALMets1Marlins2
- FINALNationals15Cubs6
- FINAL/13Reds8Brewers6
- FINALGuardians2Royals6
- FINALOrioles6Twins7
- FINALAstros0Cardinals1
- FINAL/10Dodgers4Rockies5
- FINALTigers5Angels3
- FINAL/10Athletics2Mariners4
- FINALD-backs4Giants5