Wed August 26, 2009
- FINALGuardians4Royals2
- FINALTigers2Angels4
- FINALPadres12Braves5
- FINAL/10Phillies4Pirates1
- FINALRangers2Yankees9
- FINALRays2Blue Jays3
- FINALWhite Sox2Red Sox3
- FINALMets3Marlins5
- FINALNationals4Cubs9
- FINAL/10Reds4Brewers3
- FINALOrioles5Twins1
- FINALAstros2Cardinals3
- FINALDodgers6Rockies1
- FINALAthletics3Mariners5
- FINALD-backs3Giants4