| Sat Nov 23 | vs New York | L0-2 | 1-3-0 | 3 PTS | Yankee Stadium · New York City, NY |
| Sat Nov 9 | at Cincinnati | W0-0 (6-5) | 0-3-0 | 0 PTS | TQL Stadium · Cincinnati, OH |
| Sat Nov 2 | vsCincinnati | W3-1 | 0-2-0 | 0 PTS | Yankee Stadium · New York City, NY |
| Mon Oct 28 | atCincinnati | L0-1 | 0-1-0 | 0 PTS | TQL Stadium · Cincinnati, OH |
| Sat Oct 19 | at Montreal | L0-2 | 14-12-8 | 50 PTS | Stade Saputo · Montreal, QC |
| Sun Oct 6 | vs Nashville | W3-1 | 14-11-8 | 50 PTS | Red Bull Arena · Harrison, NJ |
| Wed Oct 2 | vsCincinnati | W3-2 | 13-11-8 | 47 PTS | Red Bull Arena · Harrison, NJ |
| Sat Sep 28 | atNew York | W5-1 | 12-11-8 | 44 PTS | Red Bull Arena · Harrison, NJ |
| Sat Sep 21 | vs Miami | D1-1 | 11-11-8 | 41 PTS | Yankee Stadium · New York City, NY |
| Wed Sep 18 | vs Philadelphia | L1-5 | 11-11-7 | 40 PTS | Yankee Stadium · New York City, NY |
| Sat Sep 14 | at D.C. United | D1-1 | 11-10-7 | 40 PTS | Audi Field · Washington, D.C. |
| Sat Aug 31 | at Columbus | L2-4 | 11-10-6 | 39 PTS | Lower.com Field · Columbus, OH |
| Sat Aug 24 | vs Chicago | D2-2 | 11-9-6 | 39 PTS | Yankee Stadium · New York City, NY |
| Sat Jul 20 | at Orlando | D1-1 | 11-9-5 | 38 PTS | Exploria Stadium · Orlando, FL |
| Wed Jul 17 | at Atlanta | D2-2 | 11-9-4 | 37 PTS | Mercedes-Benz Stadium · Atlanta, GA |
| Sat Jul 13 | atChicago | D0-0 | 11-9-3 | 36 PTS | Soldier Field · Chicago, IL |
| Sat Jul 6 | at Austin | L1-2 | 11-9-2 | 35 PTS | Q2 Stadium · Austin, TX |
| Wed Jul 3 | vsMontreal | W2-0 | 11-8-2 | 35 PTS | Yankee Stadium · New York City, NY |
| Fri Jun 28 | vsOrlando | W4-2 | 10-8-2 | 32 PTS | Yankee Stadium · New York City, NY |
| Sat Jun 22 | atNashville | L0-1 | 9-8-2 | 29 PTS | GEODIS Park · Nashville, TN |
| Wed Jun 19 | at LA Galaxy | L0-2 | 9-7-2 | 29 PTS | Dignity Health Sports Park · Carson, CA |
| Fri Jun 14 | vsColumbus | L2-3 | 9-6-2 | 29 PTS | Yankee Stadium · New York City, NY |
| Fri May 31 | vs San Jose | W5-1 | 9-5-2 | 29 PTS | Yankee Stadium · New York City, NY |
| Sat May 25 | at New England | W1-0 | 8-5-2 | 26 PTS | Gillette Stadium · Foxborough, MA |
| Sat May 18 | vsNew York | W2-1 | 7-5-2 | 23 PTS | Yankee Stadium · New York City, NY |
| Wed May 15 | atPhiladelphia | W2-1 | 6-5-2 | 20 PTS | Subaru Park · Chester, PA |
| Sat May 11 | at Toronto | W3-2 | 5-5-2 | 17 PTS | BMO Field · Toronto, ON |
| Sun May 5 | vs Colorado | L0-2 | 4-5-2 | 14 PTS | Yankee Stadium · New York City, NY |
| Sat Apr 27 | vs Charlotte | W2-1 | 4-4-2 | 14 PTS | Yankee Stadium · New York City, NY |
| Sat Apr 20 | vsD.C. United | W2-0 | 3-4-2 | 11 PTS | Yankee Stadium · New York City, NY |
| Sat Apr 13 | vsNew England | W2-0 | 2-4-2 | 8 PTS | Yankee Stadium · New York City, NY |
| Sat Apr 6 | vsAtlanta | D1-1 | 1-4-2 | 5 PTS | Yankee Stadium · New York City, NY |
| Sat Mar 30 | atMiami | D1-1 | 1-4-1 | 4 PTS | DRV PNK Stadium · Fort Lauderdale, FL |
| Sat Mar 23 | atCincinnati | L0-1 | 1-4-0 | 3 PTS | TQL Stadium · Cincinnati, OH |
| Sat Mar 16 | vsToronto | W2-1 | 1-3-0 | 3 PTS | Yankee Stadium · New York City, NY |
| Sat Mar 9 | vs Portland | L1-2 | 0-3-0 | 0 PTS | Yankee Stadium · New York City, NY |
| Sat Mar 2 | at St. Louis | L0-2 | 0-2-0 | 0 PTS | CITYPARK · St. Louis, MO |
| Sat Feb 24 | atCharlotte | L0-1 | 0-1-0 | 0 PTS | Bank of America Stadium · Charlotte, NC |
