| 1 | Mon Nov 7 | at Loyola Chicago | L82-88 (OT) | 0-1 | .000 | - | | Joseph J. Gentile Arena · Chicago, IL |
| 2 | Wed Nov 9 | vs TBD | W106-66 | 1-1 | .500 | - | | Stratis Arena at the Rothman Center · Teaneck, NJ |
| 3 | Sun Nov 13 | vs Manhattan | W77-74 | 2-1 | .667 | - | | Stratis Arena at the Rothman Center · Teaneck, NJ |
| 4 | Fri Nov 18 | at SIUE | L78-79 | 2-2 | .500 | - | | First Community Arena at the Vadalabene Center · Edwardsville, IL |
| 5 | Sat Nov 19 | at Longwood | L83-99 | 2-3 | .400 | - | | Willett Hall · Farmville, VA |
| 6 | Sun Nov 20 | vs VMI | W93-89 | 3-3 | .500 | - | | Stratis Arena at the Rothman Center · Teaneck, NJ |
| 7 | Tue Nov 22 | at Pitt | L61-83 | 3-4 | .429 | - | ACC Network | Petersen Events Center · Pittsburgh, PA |
| 8 | Sun Nov 27 | at Saint Peter's | L63-77 | 3-5 | .375 | - | | Yanitelli Center · Jersey City, NJ |
| 9 | Wed Nov 30 | atTBD | L66-74 | 3-6 | .333 | - | | Chase Arena |
| 10 | Sat Dec 3 | at Saint Joseph's | W97-80 | 4-6 | .400 | - | | Michael J. Hagan '85 Arena · Philadelphia, PA |
| 11 | Fri Dec 9 | at Columbia | W76-73 (OT) | 5-6 | .455 | - | | Francis S. Levien Gymnasium · New York, NY |
| 12 | Sun Dec 11 | vs NJIT | W73-71 | 6-6 | .500 | - | | Stratis Arena at the Rothman Center · Teaneck, NJ |
| 13 | Tue Dec 13 | at Richmond | L48-77 | 6-7 | .462 | - | | Robins Center · Richmond, VA |
| 14 | Thu Dec 22 | vs Queens | L73-82 | 6-8 | .429 | - | | Stratis Arena at the Rothman Center · Teaneck, NJ |
| 15 | Thu Dec 29 | vs Merrimack | W71-63 | 7-8 | .467 | - | | Stratis Arena at the Rothman Center · Teaneck, NJ |
| 16 | Sat Dec 31 | vsTBD | W99-50 | 8-8 | .500 | - | | Stratis Arena at the Rothman Center · Teaneck, NJ |
| 17 | Thu Jan 5 | at St Francis BK | W76-57 | 9-8 | .529 | - | | Pope Physical Education Center · Brooklyn, NY |
| 18 | Sat Jan 7 | vs Long Island | W101-89 | 10-8 | .556 | - | | Stratis Arena at the Rothman Center · Teaneck, NJ |
| 19 | Sat Jan 14 | at C Connecticut | W88-80 | 11-8 | .579 | - | | William H. Detrick Gymnasium · New Britain, CT |
| 20 | Mon Jan 16 | at Stonehill | W65-57 | 12-8 | .600 | - | | placeholder · sf, ca |
| 21 | Fri Jan 20 | vs Sacred Heart | L85-92 | 12-9 | .571 | - | | Stratis Arena at the Rothman Center · Teaneck, NJ |
| 22 | Sun Jan 22 | vsStonehill | L59-70 | 12-10 | .545 | - | | Stratis Arena at the Rothman Center · Teaneck, NJ |
| 23 | Thu Jan 26 | vs St Francis PA | W87-82 | 13-10 | .565 | - | | Stratis Arena at the Rothman Center · Teaneck, NJ |
| 24 | Sat Jan 28 | atMerrimack | W78-71 | 14-10 | .583 | - | | placeholder · sf, ca |
| 25 | Sat Feb 4 | vs Wagner | L79-83 | 14-11 | .560 | - | | Stratis Arena at the Rothman Center · Teaneck, NJ |
| 26 | Thu Feb 9 | atLong Island | W80-79 | 15-11 | .577 | - | | Steinberg Wellness Center · Brooklyn, NY |
| 27 | Sat Feb 11 | vsC Connecticut | L73-77 | 15-12 | .556 | - | | Stratis Arena at the Rothman Center · Teaneck, NJ |
| 28 | Thu Feb 16 | atSacred Heart | L86-94 (OT) | 15-13 | .536 | - | | William H. Pitt Center · Fairfield, CT |
| 29 | Sat Feb 18 | atWagner | W66-48 | 16-13 | .552 | - | | Spiro Sports Center · Staten Island, NY |
| 30 | Thu Feb 23 | atSt Francis PA | L72-82 | 16-14 | .533 | - | | DeGol Arena · Loretto, PA |
| 31 | Sat Feb 25 | vsSt Francis BK | W86-69 | 17-14 | .548 | - | | Stratis Arena at the Rothman Center · Teaneck, NJ |
| 32 | Wed Mar 1 | vsSt Francis BK | W83-75 | 18-14 | .563 | - | | Stratis Arena at the Rothman Center · Teaneck, NJ |
| 33 | Sat Mar 4 | vsSt Francis PA | W70-50 | 19-14 | .576 | - | | Stratis Arena at the Rothman Center · Teaneck, NJ |
| 34 | Tue Mar 7 | atMerrimack | L66-67 | 19-15 | .559 | - | ESPN2 | placeholder · sf, ca |
| 35 | Wed Mar 15 | at #16Texas So | W84-61 | 20-15 | .571 | #16 | truTV | H&PE Arena · Houston, TX |
| 36 | Fri Mar 17 | at #1Purdue | W63-58 | 21-15 | .583 | #16 | TNT | Mackey Arena · West Lafayette, IN |
| 37 | Sun Mar 19 | at #9FAU | L70-78 | 21-16 | .568 | #16 | truTV | FAU Arena · Boca Raton, FL |
